Good Ranchers Review 2024: Is It Worth It?

Overview

Good Ranchers is a premium meat delivery service. It offers high-quality, American-sourced meats. From juicy steaks to tender chicken and seafood, its curated boxes make it easy to enjoy delicious, top-tier cuts delivered right to your door.

What sets it apart is its commitment to giving back. Every order supports Paralyzed Veterans of America, and it offers special discounts for military personnel and first responders, making it a choice you can feel good about.

Keep reading to learn more about its offerings and pricing. Plus, find out how Good Ranchers compares to other meat delivery services.

Good Ranchers’ Menu: Responsibly Sourced American Meat 

Good Ranchers is a meat delivery service that offers subscription boxes. These feature beef, pork, and chicken sourced exclusively from American farms. Its mission is to provide high-quality, ethically raised meats directly to consumers, emphasizing support for local farmers and transparency in sourcing.

Good Ranchers sources its meat from local, independent farms in the US. This ensures that all products are 100% American and never imported. This approach not only provides customers with top-quality products but also supports local farmers and promotes ethical farming practices.

Meal Options: Curated Boxes, Add-Ons & Gift Boxes

Good Ranchers offers curated boxes with single meats or combinations. Choose from beef, pork, chicken, or seafood. The Essentials Box is the most popular, featuring a mix of chicken and beef cuts.

Other boxes include the Better Than Organic Chicken, which boasts superior treatment to organic-raised chicken. It contains both marinated and plain chicken cuts. You can also get a Surf and Turf Box (beef and seafood) or a Family Feast Bundle with 8 different items.

After selecting your box, you can choose add-ons to personalize your order. It’s a great way to add your favorite cuts. I also like that you can send a box as a gift or place a one-time order. 

Customization: You Can’t Edit the Contents of Your Box 

Customization with Good Ranchers mainly comes from selecting your box. You can add extras, but that’ll increase your total cost. The add-ons can be filtered by meat type. You can also sort by price or popularity to help narrow your choices.

It would be nice to customize individual boxes like with Good Chop. According to the customer service agent, this feature is in the works. If you want to avoid certain meats, you can check the box contents. Alternatively, take the selection quiz to find the best fit for your needs.

Good Ranchers’ Menu at a Glance 

Unboxing: Handle With Care & Make Room in the Freezer!

Your Good Ranchers box arrives packed with insulation. It also contains dry ice to keep your meat frozen during transit. If dry ice is still present when your package arrives, handle it with caution. For safe handling, use tongs or gloves, and let any remaining dry ice evaporate in a well-ventilated area. 

Make sure you’ve cleared plenty of freezer space, especially if you’ve ordered add-ons. If your meat arrives partially thawed but still cold to the touch, it’s safe to store in the refrigerator or freezer thanks to vacuum-sealing. However, if the contents are not cold to the touch upon arrival, contact the customer service team right away.

Cooking With Good Ranchers: Get Creative With Different Recipes!

Good Ranchers delivers premium cuts of frozen meat. Proper thawing is essential for maintaining freshness and flavor. For best results, thaw your meat in the refrigerator overnight. You can find meat cooking tips and recipes on the Good Ranchers’ website. Ultimately, how you cook it is completely up to you.

Shortlist of My Favorite Meals

The Angus Ground Beef features in the most popular box on Good Ranchers’ menu. The Essentials box includes 4 packs of the Angus Ground Beef as well as 8 Pre-Trimmed Plain Chicken Breasts, 2 Strip-Cut Plain Chicken packs, and 2 Sirloin Steak Tip packs. 

Angus ground beef is a versatile ingredient perfect for a variety of dishes. Use it to make classic burgers, hearty meatballs, or savory meatloaf by mixing in simple seasonings, breadcrumbs, or cheese. It’s also great for quick and easy meals like tacos, sloppy joes, or spaghetti Bolognese.

The Italian Seasoned Chicken Breast is a flavorful option. It’s perfect for quick meals like pasta, salads, or paninis. Grill, bake, or slice it for wraps and meal prep. Its versatile seasoning pairs well with roasted veggies, rice, or marinara for an easy Italian-inspired dish.

Alaskan Halibut Filets are delicate, flaky white fish with a mild flavor. They’re perfect for a variety of cooking methods. Whether you grill, bake, or pan-sear, these filets cook quickly and make a light, healthy meal. Serve with a squeeze of lemon, alongside roasted vegetables or a fresh salad, for a simple and delicious seafood dish.

Prices: From Affordable Options to Premium Cuts

Pricing for Good Ranchers varies depending on the box you choose. The most affordable option is the Burger Box, priced at $129 for 24 American Wagyu and Angus burger patties. At the higher end, the Butcher’s Bundle costs $329 and includes a mix of chicken and beef cuts. The Essentials Box is the most popular, priced at $149.

Extras can be added to your order, with prices starting from $9.99 for 4 sausages and going up to $99.99 for 4 Center-Cut Filet Mignons (6 oz). Keep in mind that adding extras can significantly increase the total cost of your order.

Shipping is generally free with a subscription, but Good Ranchers reserves the right to adjust or remove shipping charges at any time. It also offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, though you’ll need to contact customer service to resolve any issues.

Shipping & Delivery: You Can’t Choose a Specific Delivery Day

Good Ranchers delivers exclusively to the continental US, excluding Alaska and Hawaii. Once your box is shipped, you’ll receive a tracking email to monitor its progress. While you don’t need to be home for delivery, it’s best to collect your box within 3-5 hours, especially during hot weather, to ensure freshness.

Unfortunately, you can’t select a specific delivery day. This might be inconvenient if your box arrives in the morning and you’re not home to collect it promptly.

How Good Ranchers Works (Step by Step Guide)

Good Ranchers is a meat subscription service. You can order curated boxes of your favorite cuts of meat. You can also place a one-time order or send products as a gift.

How to Sign up (Just 5 Simple Steps)

1. Head to the Good Ranchers website and click on Start Now. This takes you to the box selection page.

2. Check through the available boxes and choose your favorite. Then click on Add to Cart. 

3. Decide on your subscription frequency. You can place a one-time order or have a recurring delivery every 2, 4, or 6 weeks. You can also add your coupon code at this stage.

4. Click Begin Checkout. You’ll see a range of add-ons you can add to your first order.

5. Enter your address and payment details. Then wait for your Good Ranchers’ meat to arrive. 

Managing Your Subscription

You can adjust, delay, or update your subscription from your account page. Make any changes or contact support at least 3 days before your order is processed. Orders marked as "Awaiting Fulfillment" or "Awaiting Shipment" can’t be changed or canceled.

Customer Service: Limited Contact Options & No Live Chat

Good Ranchers offers customer support via phone at 346-474-4663. This is available Monday to Friday from 8 am to 6 pm CST and on Saturdays from 8 am to 4 pm. You can also email [email protected] for assistance. However, it’s disappointing that there’s no live chat or chatbot for quicker responses.

I emailed to inquire about customization options and received a detailed and friendly reply, though it took 8 hours. The FAQ on the website is also limited, so support may require a longer wait for more specific questions.

How Good Ranchers Compares to Other Meat Delivery Services

Good Ranchers vs. Good Chop: Good Chop stands out for its wider variety of sustainably sourced meats and seafood, including wild-caught options. If sustainability and diverse choices are a priority, Good Chop is a better fit.

Good Ranchers vs. ButcherBox: Good Ranchers focuses on American meats with simple, curated box options, while ButcherBox offers more variety and customizable subscriptions.

The Bottom Line: Is Good Ranchers Worth It?

Good Ranchers is worth it if you’re happy with a curated selection. You’ll receive high-quality, American-sourced meats. The service offers convenience, with a variety of box options like the Essentials Box and Butcher's Bundle, making it easy to stock up on premium meats without having to choose every cut.

However, if you prefer more flexibility and the ability to customize your orders, Good Chop may be a better choice. It offers a wider variety of meats, including seafood, and allows you to tailor your box to suit your preferences.

However, Good Ranchers is also a good option for gifting or if you just want a one-time order. If you want to explore more choices, take a look at our guide to the best meat delivery services to find the right fit for your needs.

FAQ

Where does Good Ranchers meat come from?

Good Ranchers sources all its meat from local, independent US farms. The menu features high-quality, American-sourced products.

What is the best online meat company?

Determining the "best" online meat company depends on individual preferences. Good Ranchers is known for its curated selection of American-sourced meats, while other companies may offer more customization options.

Who owns Good Ranchers?

Good Ranchers was founded by Ben and Corley Spell. They started the company to provide honest and quality food for their growing family.

Can you cancel a Good Ranchers subscription?

Yes, you can cancel your Good Ranchers subscription at any time. Manage your subscription in your account page or contact the customer service team.