9 Best Chewy Cat Foods 2024: Expert Top Picks

We all want to give our cats the best nutrition possible. With so many cat food options available on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. Whether you have a picky eater, a cat with special dietary needs, or just want to provide a variety of flavors, Chewy has an extensive selection of cat food that can cater to all of your cat's needs.

After researching the options available on Chewy, I’ve come up with the best cat food picks that offer high-quality ingredients, a range of flavors, and cater to various dietary needs. The options range from wet food to dry food, and each is crafted to provide essential nutrients to help your cat maintain overall health. Every option contains the recommended amount of taurine, which is essential for a cat’s development.

My top recommendation is the Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Variety Pack. This canned cat food is made with high-quality ingredients, featuring tender cuts of grilled seafood infused with a savory broth. Let’s take a look at all the options that made it onto my list.

The Best Chewy Cat Food Picks Meals Reviewed

1. Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood – Best Overall Cat Food Brand on Chewy

Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Variety Pack Canned Cat Food is a popular cat food made with high-quality ingredients. It provides balanced and complete nutrition for cats of all ages. This is useful if you have more than 1 cat at different life stages. The cans are easy to open and serve, making mealtime quick and convenient.

This variety pack includes 3 different flavors: Grilled Tuna Feast in Gravy, Grilled Salmon Feast in Gravy, and Grilled Seafood Feast in Gravy. The guaranteed analysis shows that the nutritional values are identical for each item. Each can contains a savory blend of real seafood that’s cooked then simmered in a rich gravy to enhance the flavor and texture.

It’s made with real fish and seafood, providing a rich source of protein and other essential nutrients that help to support your cat's overall health and well-being. This cat food is also free from artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. 

For the best value, choose the case of 24, which currently retails at $0.25/oz. Note that this particular item isn't suitable for cats with grain allergies.

2. Friskies Shreds in Gravy – Best Low-Calorie Cat Food on Chewy

Friskies Shreds Variety Pack Canned Cat Food is a popular and affordable option for cat owners looking to provide their pets with a balanced meal. It comes in 4 flavors, which is especially handy if you have multiple cats with different tastes.

This variety pack includes 40 cans, with 10 cans of each of the 4 flavors: Turkey & Cheese, Beef, Ocean Whitefish & Tuna, and Chicken & Salmon. Each can contains 5.5 ounces of food and features tender shreds of real meat in a savory gravy that’s easy for cats to digest. The products are free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives.

The price point for this variety pack is attractive compared to other wet food options on the market, making it an affordable option. Some reviews mentioned that the food is a bit on the watery side. But most report that their cats enjoy it and lick their plates clean.

3. Purina Friskies Seafood & Chicken Paté – Best Value Paté Cat Food on Chewy

This is a great value variety pack of wet cat food. Each case comes with 40 cans containing 5.5 ounces of food in different flavors, such as chicken, tuna, and salmon. Other ingredients depend on the recipe but may include rice, minerals, and vitamins. The mix of flavors means cats won't get bored.

Nutritional content differs across products, with crude fiber consistently maxing out at 1%. Other nutritional elements have at least 9% crude protein and a minimum of 4% crude fat.

Many customers report that their cats enjoy the smooth and creamy paté texture, which is easy to eat and digest. This makes it a good option to try with your senior cat or if your cat has digestive issues. If your cat isn’t keen on paté textures, you could try a shredded texture instead. I’d opt for the Friskies Shreds to switch things up a bit.

4. Fancy Feast Savory Centers – Best Chewy Cat Food for Senior Cats

Fancy Feast Savory Centers is an ideal option for senior cats. The moisture from the real broth helps to keep them hydrated, which is especially important for senior cats or cats with urinary tract issues.

This variety pack features 24 cans in 4 different recipes: salmon, tuna, chicken, and beef, meaning your cat gets a range of flavors. The double textures of these recipes offer a smooth, light paté with a thick, meaty gravy. The hidden gravy center is a unique gourmet feature that many cats love, although it does come with a gourmet price tag.

It’s a good option for cats with certain allergies, as all recipes are grain-free. It may even help improve some digestive issues. If you’re transitioning your cat from another food, though,  you should do this gradually over 10 days. Each day, add 10% of Fancy Feast Savory Centers food while reducing the old food by the same percentage. 

5. Fancy Feast Classic Seafood Feast – Best Seafood-Based Chewy Cat Food

This variety pack features a range of delicious seafood-based flavors in 24 cans. These include cod, sole and shrimp, savory salmon, and ocean whitefish and tuna, all of which are listed as the first ingredient. The smooth, soft paté texture is paired with a savory cat food gravy that adds to the deliciousness of each recipe.

Each meal is free from artificial colors or preservatives and is also worth considering if you're in search of grain-free cat food (or have a cat with certain food sensitivities). 

The small size of the cans makes them easy to store and the variety means you can tempt fussy cats with a different flavor at every mealtime. However, if you have more than 1 cat, a larger pack like the Purina Friskies paté recipes might be more convenient. 

6. Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef – Best Fish-Free Cat Food on Chewy

The Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef Feast Variety Pack is a great option if you want to avoid seafood for your cat. In each pack, there’s an even mix of Turkey Feast, Chicken Feast, and Beef Feast. Each recipe contains bite-sized meaty pieces that are gently cooked and served in a thick gravy.

There’s 100% complete nutrition with every serving, ensuring that your cat gets all the essential vitamins, minerals, and taurine they need. Purina prepares these meals at its own facilities in the USA and they contain no preservatives or artificial colors.

To find out more about Chewy’s ordering and delivery process, check out our tested Chewy review, where our furry reviewer Alvy tried some of Chewy’s top cat food options. 

7. Fancy Feast Delights With Cheddar – Best Cat Food Topper Option

This collection of high-quality cat food is infused with aged cheddar cheese and slow-cooked to retain flavor. You can even mix it with dry food as a topper for a unique texture that cats love.

While each recipe includes cheese, the variety pack combines this with 3 different grilled meat flavors, including chicken, turkey, and whitefish, which is ideal for introducing variety at dinnertime. Recipes are made in the US, and each entrée offers complete nutrition to support and maintain your cat's health. 

With the handy flip-top designed can, serving this food is really easy. However, some customers reported that their cats aren’t fans of the cheesy recipes. If that’s your cat, I suggest trying the Fancy Feast Grilled recipes instead, which have a similar texture.

8. Purina Cat Chow Naturals – Highest Protein Dry Food on Chewy

This is the only dry food recipe on my list, and it’s packed with protein. A diet high in protein helps cats feel full and satisfied, which can prevent overeating and contribute to maintaining a healthy weight. It’s best suited for high-protein, weight-control, and indoor cat diets.

Purina Cat Chow Naturals Original with Added Vitamins, Minerals & Nutrients is a dry cat food made with top-quality ingredients, including real chicken as the primary ingredient. It also contains salmon and whole grains. 

With 25 important vitamins and minerals and omega-6, this recipe supports your cat’s skin and keeps its coat healthy for hairball control.  It doesn't contain artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives and is formulated for all life stages. 

9. Friskies Classic Paté Variety Pack – Best Cat Food for All Life Stages

The Friskies Classic Paté Variety Pack is a good option for all life stages of cats. The formula is made with real meat, which provides high-quality protein for muscle maintenance and growth, essential for kittens and adult cats alike.

The pack includes 24 5.5-ounce cans of favorite recipes. Each features real meat, including chicken, tuna, and turkey, in a savory sauce. One of the key ingredients in this cat food is essential taurine, which plays an important role in maintaining heart and eye health. 

These high-protein meals are perfect for satisfying your little carnivore's natural cravings. Plus, because the paté is made with real broth, it helps keep your cat hydrated and supports urinary health. You can serve it on its own or as a topper for your cat’s current kibble.

Quick Comparison Table

FAQ

What types of cat food are available on Chewy?

Chewy offers a wide variety of cat foods, including dry food, wet food, raw food, freeze-dried food, and dehydrated food. There are also foods suitable for a range of nutritional needs, such as high-protein diets and grain-free options.

How do I know which cat food is best for my cat?

The best cat food for your cat depends on their age, weight, health condition, and dietary preferences. It's always a good idea to consult with your veterinarian to determine the most appropriate diet for your cat. Your cat might prefer a particular texture of food such as paté recipes or chunks in gravy.

What is the difference between regular cat food and grain-free cat food?

Regular cat food has grains like wheat, corn, and rice, which can provide carbs and energy for cats. Grain-free cat food doesn't have these grains and might be better for cats with food sensitivities or allergies.