7 Best Meal Delivery Services in Indianapolis 2024

Meal delivery services are the best way to enjoy new flavors and healthy meals in Indianapolis. Whether you are in search of hearty meal kits to feed a crowd or diet-friendly dinners for 1, your perfect delivery match is out there.

All the services on my list use high-quality ingredients and employ experienced chefs to prepare tasty meals or craft recipes you can cook at home. Some of them even allow customers to customize dishes to some extent by replacing or removing certain ingredients. Their delivery's punctual, and several providers let you choose your exact delivery day.

After careful examination, I found that Factor is the best Indianapolis meal delivery service. It has various diet plans, offers good value for money, and is quite convenient. Besides a great variety of prepared meals, it also sells a wide range of extras and add-ons.

The Best Meal Delivery Services in Indianapolis Reviewed

1. Factor – Best Prepared Meals in Indianapolis

Factor specializes in fresh, prepared meals for various diets. If you're a carb-conscious, vegetarian, or vegan dieter, you'll find dozens of options on Factor's menu. The service's ready-made food caters to high-protein and keto foodies, too.

What’s on the Menu?

The menu features around 35 recipes, and it’s easily navigable despite having no filters. Instead, tags helped me distinguish keto, calorie-smart, and protein-rich recipes. Top-Rated tags mark popular dishes, and new recipes are labeled, too.

There are also 40+ extras, including treats, side dishes, and drinks. In our review, we were impressed by the options available, such as pancakes, small bites, cakes, juices, and smoothies.

Factor offers 6 meal categories but you can mix and match these when choosing your meals:

• Chef's Choice – balanced meals catering to various lifestyles

• Keto – high-fat, low-carb recipes

• Calorie Smart – dietitian-approved meals with less than 550 calories per serving

• Vegan & Veggie – meat-free dishes

• Protein Plus – meals with at least 30 grams of protein per serving

• Flexitarian – veggie-centered meals for those following a flexitarian diet

What Makes It Special?

Factor has strict standards regarding ingredient sourcing, and its chefs prepare healthy food according to dietitians' recommendations. For this reason, you won't be able to replace or remove ingredients, so check each meal’s ingredients carefully if you have an allergy.

If you have any dietary concerns, you can chat with 1 of Factor's certified dietitians. You'll get a free 20-minute coaching session with a nutrition coach who’ll give you personalized tips and assistance with setting nutrition goals. According to customer testimonials, these sessions proved helpful.

Is It Good Value?

Factor’s prices vary depending on how many single-serving meals you need each week. The larger the order, the lower the cost per meal. For example, its best-value box gives you 18 meals for just $103.41 on your first order if you use our link.

2. Green Chef – Best Organic Food Provider in the Indiana Capital

Green Chef is a popular, certified-organic meal delivery service. The company is the first organic meal kit provider certified by California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF). Owned by HelloFresh since 2018, Green Chef is a premium brand offering recipes made from organically sourced and sustainably produced meat, produce, and seafood.

What’s on the Menu?

There are more than 40 dishes per week on the Green Chef menu. On the website, each recipe features an image, an ingredient list, prep time, and basic nutritional info. We were impressed by the flavors when we tested the service out. 

Tags such as Keto, Mediterranean, and Sodium Smart help you shortlist your favorite food. You'll also find Veggie, Gluten-Free, and Protein Packed tags. All keto meals are also gluten-free, so gluten-free keto dieters will have a lot of choices.

You can build your meal plan by selecting up to 8 of the following categories:

• Keto – meals free of soy, grains, and gluten

• Plant Based – plant-based proteins, grains, and veggies

• Mediterranean – combining vegetables and beneficial fats

• Gut & Brain Health – high-fiber recipes with fresh ingredients

• Quick & Easy – meals ready in 25 minutes or less

• Gluten Free – allergy-friendly dishes free from gluten

• Protein Packed – high-protein options

• Calorie Smart – meals with a maximum of 650 calories

Green Chef offers add-ons as well as its main dishes. These include ground meat, cutlets, filets, and pizza. There are also sweet treats, like muffins and pancakes.

What Makes It Special?

You can mix and match meals from across all categories. The categories you choose simply re-order the menu so the recipes that meet your preferences appear first. You'll still see recipes from unselected categories when browsing the menu, so be mindful of this if you have allergies.

Green Chef's meals are usually fresh up to 5 days after delivery if you put them in the fridge. However, you should eat seafood within 3 days of the delivery.

Is It Good Value?

Most of Green Chef's ingredients are organic, but not all. When the company can't source organic components, it'll inform you about non-organic elements via in-box communication and labeling. Even so, the service sources only top-quality ingredients that go through rigorous quality checks.

Green Chef is a premium service, but it can still work out as good value. The cost per serving starts at $9.99 for the maximum order of 4 weekly meals for 6 people. The minimum weekly order is 3 recipes for 2 people. 

3. Blue Apron – Best International Meal Delivery Service in Indianapolis

Blue Apron offers meal kits  and prepared meals for people with a range of different dietary needs. A team of expert chefs – who have cooked in reputable restaurants around the world – crafts each recipe. You can prepare most Blue Apron meal kits in less than 45 minutes and the Prepared & Ready meals take just a few minutes.

What’s on the Menu?

Blue Apron publishes its weekly menu for the upcoming 4 weeks, so you can plan ahead. The menu is sorted by 4 chief categories:

• Meal kits for 2 – featuring meat, fish, and vegetarian meals portioned for couples

• Meal kits for 4 – featuring omnivorous recipes for families

• Prepared & Ready – prepared meals portioned for 1 person

• Add-Ons – consisting of appetizers, desserts, side dishes, and proteins

Dietary accommodations include carb-conscious, calorie-conscious, high protein, and pescatarian options, among others.

What Makes It Special?

In our review, we liked the handy menu tags that help you find the right meal. For example, Make It Vegetarian highlights dishes you can make vegetarian by swapping out the meat. Ready To Cook indicates a quick recipe that just needs some assembly and cooking.

You can customize selected dishes further by swapping 1 type of meat for another. I found that you can replace bistro steaks with tenderloin or ribeye steaks in some meals. In others, you can choose between thinly sliced beef and bistro steaks.

Is It Good Value?

The minimum weekly meal kit order is 2 meals with 2 servings, while the maximum order is 5 meals with 4 servings. You can also order additional meals with each weekly order. The prepared meals can be ordered as a bundle of 4, 6, 8, or 10.

The price per recipe starts at $4.00 and applies to the maximum order. The fewer dishes you order, the higher the price per serving you'll pay.

4. HelloFresh – Best for Indianapolis Families

HelloFresh has a huge weekly menu of meal kits. It has over 100 weekly rotating recipes and market items on its menu. These could be variations of the same meal, such as Zucchini & Tomato Flatbreads and Roasted Garlic & Zucchini Flatbreads, or the same meal with a different protein.

What’s on the Menu?

HelloFresh features high-quality ingredients. Its team pre-measures each ingredient before packing them in the meal kit, as noted in our tried-and-tested review.  There are lots of options if you eat a balanced, low-carb, pescatarian, or low-calorie diet. There are also kits for lovers of spicy food, too. 

You can personalize your plan from any of the following 6 meal categories:

• Veggie

• Pescatarian

• Meat & Veggies

• Family Friendly

• Under 20 Minutes

• Fit & Wholesome

What Makes It Special?

You can customize some HelloFresh recipes with HelloCustom. This useful feature is available with every plan, and it allows you to upgrade or replace sides and proteins for selected meals. You can swap potatoes for broccoli or chicken for steak, for example.

You'll also find many useful tags while browsing HelloFresh's menu. These include:

• Hall of Fame – the most popular dishes among customers

• Best Recipe – top meals of the year

• Premium Picks – recipes with premium ingredients

• 10-Min Lunch – easy cleanup specialties

Is It Good Value?

HelloFresh offers competitive pricing among meal delivery services. Larger meal boxes come at a higher overall cost but offer better per-serving rates, while smaller boxes cost more per serving. For instance, if you order 6 meals for 4 people, your first box costs $107.75 with our link. Shipping fees remain constant, regardless of box size.

5. Home Chef – Best for Building a Long-Term Meal Plan

Home Chef is an excellent option for people who plan their meals ahead. The service designs and publishes its menu 6 weeks in advance. It has a wide selection of main dishes and add-ons, so you'll have lots of options to build your meal plan each week. You'll always find well over 30 meals and dozens of extras on the menu.

What’s on the Menu?

Home Chef caters to omnivores, vegetarians, and pescatarians, as well as low-calorie and low-carb dieters. High-protein eaters and fans of spicy food will find suitable options, too. 

Home Chef offers meal kits and prepared meals. Meal kits are best if you're willing to spend time cooking, and prepared meals are ideal if you prefer the heat-and-eat approach. Its range of low-prep meal kits can be ready between 10 and 60 minutes. The longer recipes are still simple – they’re usually dishes that are ready to be heated in the oven.

Extras comprise appetizers, sides, and desserts for the most part. Home Chef has a huge range, which can help limit trips to the grocery store. Soups, salads, steaks, and more are on offer, too.

What Makes It Special?

The Customize It feature lets you personalize selected dishes. In our review, we found that this option was available for most of the menu. It allows you to upgrade or change your protein. For example, you can swap ground turkey with ground pork or replace shrimp with scallops.

You can choose certain ingredients to avoid while personalizing your recipe selection. Sesame, mushrooms, tree nuts, and various types of meat are a few options you may choose to leave out. You can also specify if you prefer carb-conscious or calorie-conscious dishes at this stage.

Is It Good Value?

The price starts at $9.99 per serving, although you’ll often pay more than that as each meal has its own price. You won’t pay a high per-serving price for a small order, so small families won’t feel penalized. 

The minimum order is 2 meals for 2 people, and the maximum order is 6 recipes for 6 people. This makes Home Chef great for large families.

6. BistroMD – Best for Customizable Weight-Loss Plans

BistroMD specializes in weight-loss plans suitable for people with various health conditions and dietary preferences. It hires licensed dietitians who design meals and experienced chefs who prepare them. With BistroMD, you won't have to skimp on meals, and you may see the results within 10 days.

What’s on the Menu?

BistroMD prepares mostly American and Italian specialties. You can find out more about the meals in our dedicated review. The service has specially designed programs for women and men. It has 7 plans you can choose from:

• Signature – 150+ meals without artificial ingredients

• Gluten Free – 100+ dishes lacking wheat, barley, and rye

• Heart Healthy – 100+ dishes with controlled sodium and fat levels

• Keto Flex – 85+ meals with low-carbohydrate levels

• Diabetic – 100+ meals with less than 25 g of carbs

• Menopause – 100+ recipes designed to help with hormone changes

• Vegan – 35+ plant-based lunch and dinner recipes

Customize your weight-loss diet by selecting a 7-day (Full Week) or 5-day (Work Week) program. The former comprises 7 breakfasts, 7 lunches, 6 dinners, and My Night that you can use to treat yourself to anything you want. The latter consists of 5 breakfasts, lunches, and dinners.

Besides meals, BistroMD has snacks on offer. These include cakes, juices, cookies, and chips, and they all work with the overall diet plan.

What Makes It Special? 

You're free to personalize your weight loss by choosing a Custom Program. Select this plan if you wish to have only lunches or dinners, for example. You can call BistroMD's dietary experts to get help with diet customization.

The provider delivers frozen meals. You can store them in the freezer or put them in the fridge to thaw. Dishes are usually safe to eat for 2 or 3 days following thawing. Most BistroMD's prepared meals take up to 5 minutes to heat in the microwave.

Is It Good Value?

The more dishes you order, the lower the price per individual dish you pay. The price per serving starts at $6.59. The maximum weekly order is 20 meals – 7 breakfasts and lunches and 6 dinners with the Full Week Program. The minimum purchase is 5 lunches and dinners for the Work Week Program.

You'll also have to pay a $19.95 shipping rate, which is quite expensive. FedEx handles delivery, and you'll get the tracking info as soon as the courier takes over your package.

7. Trifecta – Great for Meal Plan Personalization

Trifecta is a versatile meal delivery service allowing you to personalize different meal plans. You can choose between 4 meal plans depending on your dietary requirements. The Trifecta team curates the menu weekly, while expert dietitians design each dish. Choose your meals or let Trifecta’s experts pick for you.

What’s on the Menu?

Trifecta meal plans are:

• Keto: The most popular program features foods with high healthy fats and protein and low carb levels.

• Paleo Whole30: Meals that suit both paleo and Whole30 diets

• Clean: Protein-rich meals with grains and organic vegetables

• Plant Based: High-protein vegan and vegetarian dishes

You can choose Meal Prep and Classics dishes from Trifecta's menu. Meal Prep options typically feature 4 servings of proteins, carbs, and veggies. Classic dishes such as egg scramble and mixed vegetables are rich in protein and feature moderate carb and low-fat levels. Find out more about the menu in our Trifecta review.

You can choose 5, 7, 10, or 14 entrées. If you choose 7 entrées or more, you can skip ordering breakfast. If you only want 5 entrées then you must add 5 breakfasts. You can exclude 1 or 2 ingredients from a list of around 10. These include mushrooms, shellfish, salmon, and tree nuts.

What Makes It Special?

Trifecta meals are made with high-quality ingredients like organic produce and grass-fed, free-range, and sustainably harvested proteins.

Most recipes contain between 350 and 500 calories. You should eat them no later than 7 days after delivery. To extend the shelf-life you can freeze them, but they might taste different once they thaw.

Is It Good Value?

The price per meal you pay depends on the meal plan and the number of servings you select. The more dishes you buy, the lower the cost per serving will be. Plant Based programs are less expensive than others. The price per recipe starts from $13.79 . The minimum weekly order is 7 dishes while the maximum purchase is 21.

Indianapolis residents will pay an additional shipping fee. GSO, UPS, or FedEx usually deliver orders on Friday or Saturday.

Quick Comparison Table

Tips for Choosing the Best Meal Delivery Service in Indianapolis

Now you know what the top-rated meal kit and prepared meals delivery services in Indianapolis are. Consider the following steps to figure out which is best for you:

• Determine your dietary goals. If you’re physically active, then you’ll benefit from high-protein foods such as those offered by Factor. If weight loss is your goal, then look for a service with low-calorie meals or a dedicated weight-loss plan such as BistroMD.

• Assess your availability: If you have ample time to cook, meal kits could be a good fit. However, if you're more of a heat-and-eat type of person with little time, opt for prepared meals. Most of these can be heated in the microwave in a few minutes. Blue Apron offers meal kits and prepared meals on the weekly menu.

• Plan your budget: The meal delivery services in Indianapolis on my list give good value for money. Think about your own budget to pick the right one for you. Don't forget to include the shipping cost if the service you pick doesn't offer free delivery.

• Examine delivery terms: Some services deliver meals on specified days, while others leave it to their couriers. Some even let customers pick their delivery days. Enquire about driver flexibility and whether they will leave the box at your door or with a neighbor if you're not around.
  

FAQ

What’s the best meal delivery service in Indianapolis?

Factor is 1 of my favorite meal delivery services in Indianapolis. It features a weekly menu of prepared meals that suit a range of diets. It also offers a respectable number of extras and add-ons.  

Are delivered meal plans worth it?

For some, yes. If you enjoy the convenience of not having to plan and shop for your meals, that is. Delivered meal plans can help save you a tremendous amount of time and hassle, like the delicious meals available from Green Chef (which also happen to be USDA-certified organic!).

What’s the best diet meal delivery in Indianapolis?

BistroMD is the top diet meal delivery service in Indianapolis. It specializes in weight-loss programs designed by doctors that are suitable for a range of health conditions.

Best Meal Delivery Service in Indianapolis in 2024 – Final Score